Note: This is the oldest poem I've included in this anthology, dating back to 2021. Please ignore its rustiness.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was three
Running around the playground.
Every day, I would ask to play the prince
Who ran in to save little girls
From the ferocious dragon.
I didn’t know why, but prince always fit me
Better than princess.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was eight
And I felt more comfortable in my brother’s
Hand-me-downs than anything else.
“She’s a tomboy,” everyone said proudly
And I was proud too, nestled safely inside
My favorite leather jacket.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was thirteen
With short hair and a stack of stories a mile high
Of self-insert characters with imaginary role-models
That were, for some reason, mostly male.
But the shame started quickly then —
I didn’t just look like a boy, but
I was an ugly boy
That nobody wanted.
I decided to never look
Like a boy again.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was sixteen
And I was jealous of my boyfriend
For his height and strength.
I wanted to be tall and strong —
I wanted to love and protect and hold.
I wanted to be romantic the way “boys were supposed to be”.
I started bringing my friends chocolates and flowers
And taking them on dates.
But I didn’t want to be a boy,
So I figured there was nothing more to it.
I wish that I’d known that there were
More options.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was nineteen
And I dressed in dresses and heels everyday.
I was feminine, EXTREMELY feminine,
Feminine as if I’d looked at a photo of a woman
And tried to emulate it.
I didn’t like the dresses and the shoes hurt my toes,
But I liked the way people responded to me.
They told me I was beautiful, they respected me,
And I loved the compliments.
I wore “female” like a performance
That I took off when I got home.
She and I were separate entities.
I should have known I was non-binary
When I was twenty-one
And I chopped my hair short again
After years of deliberation.
I loved the sudden joy I felt, the rush of “right-ness”
When I looked in the mirror.
But the affirmations at home ended after that:
My mother cried for my fallen locks
And “dyke” and “man” were hurled as insults by classmates.
I curled around the remnants of traditional femininity that I had left,
Stoking them and hoping that maybe
Anyone would call me
Beautiful again.
I should have known I was non-binary every day after that.
I should have known at twenty-two
when I asked to change the pronouns
of my D&D character.
I should have known at twenty-three
When I first changed my pen name to
Something intentionally ambiguous.
At twenty-four, I first tried to come out
But my partner said he couldn't love me if I wasn’t “she”,
So I abandoned my exploration
(Though I knew in the back of my mind
That something wasn’t right.)
I started to know at twenty-five, but I
Was so elated with discovering I was a lesbian
That I focused on that revelation first,
Overwhelmed with a difficult year.
At twenty-six, the floodgates opened
After a toe-dip into she/they pronouns
That only lasted a few months.
I cried with joy the first time I wore my binder
And I cried with fear that my family wouldn’t accept me.
But my new name fit like that leather jacket when I was seven,
And I finally was the prince I wanted to be when I was three,
And suddenly I was the role-model I had written about when I was thirteen
And the loving, protective partner I wanted to be in my teens.
The elation of being seen made me forget the truth —
That I was right to be afraid.
That not everyone would love me as me,
Even those I wanted to love me the most.
(Not even my longest friend.)
But even now, brokenhearted and too overwhelmed
by the future to get out of bed,
I’m still me.
I can’t change it now.
I don’t want to.
I’m sorry that they can only love a person who,
When I look back now,
I realize never really existed.
“She” was a performance
And I cannot be loved for something I am not.
I cannot live on conditional half-love
Now that I have known the sustenance
Of the truth.